Free shipping or 10% off?

🥊 Free shipping vs 10% off for your Black Friday week, the checkout surprise behind 70% cart abandonment, and more!

Share

Hey there Smarty 👋

Are you geared up to catch the latest and greatest in quick shorts?

And just a quick heads-up! If you stumbled upon us through a friend, make sure to subscribe here! That way, you’ll never miss out on the trending shorts.

🥊 Free shipping vs 10% off: which offer should lead your black friday week?

Discounts will dominate next week's ads. Free shipping gets far less attention, and the choice between them deserves a real comparison. 

Take a store with a $70 average order that pays $8 to ship it. Ten percent off costs $7 per order. Free shipping costs $8. On paper, they're the same offer. They don't behave the same. Five rounds; numbers are illustrative unless sourced.

Round 1: The checkout surprise

Baymard Institute's research puts the average documented cart abandonment rate at 70.22%, and the top reason, excluding people just browsing, is extra costs such as shipping, tax and fees, cited by 40% of US shoppers who abandoned. A discount shows on the product page, then shipping still appears at checkout. Free shipping removes the surprise at the exact moment people leave.

Winner: free shipping.

Round 2: Pull in the ad

"10% off" is easy to read but easy to ignore when competitors run 25% or more. "Free shipping" is easy to overlook too. Neither wins on headline pull in Black Friday week. A bigger percentage beats both, at a much higher cost.

Winner: tie.

Round 3: Average order value

Ten percent off scales with the basket, so bigger orders cost you more. Free shipping over a threshold works the other way: set it at $85, about 20% above your average order, and shoppers at $70 have a reason to add a $15 item. If enough of them do, the margin on those add-ons can cover the shipping, so check it against your own numbers.

Winner: free shipping, with a threshold.

Round 4: Cost control

A 10% discount costs exactly 10% on every order. Shipping cost varies with weight and distance, so a heavy order shipped across the country can cost far more than $8. Check your shipping spend by order size before committing.

Winner: discount, for predictability.

Round 5: What January remembers

Shoppers who bought at 10% off may wait for the next sale. Free shipping over a threshold can stay as a permanent policy, so January's full-price ads don't fight the memory of a markdown.

Winner: free shipping.

The verdict

Test free shipping over a threshold your margins can support; $85 is an illustrative starting point for a $70 average order. State the threshold clearly in ads and emails. Compare orders and profit with a 10% offer before choosing a winner. Add a discount on top, or keep free shipping into December, only if the combined costs still work. 

Pull your last 90 days of orders tonight and check what share sits just under $85. That shows where to test the threshold, not how many shoppers will add more. 

Together with Omnisend

Get their email while you have their attention 

You spend hours creating content that gets people interested. Then ask them to find your bio, open a link, and fill out a form.

Every extra step gives a potential subscriber another reason to drop off.

Omnisend’s Social Capture lets you collect their email right inside Instagram, while they’re already engaging with your brand. 

Here’s how it works:

  • Connect Instagram and choose a keyword, with an optional discount for subscribing.
  • Omnisend automatically DMs anyone who comments or messages that keyword, asking for their email.
  • Those who subscribe go straight into your Omnisend list, ready for your welcome series.

You’ll have a way to follow up with interested shoppers when your next offer goes live, without hoping they see another post.

New to Omnisend? Its e-commerce email and SMS platform is trusted by 150,000+ brands. Migration is free and takes up to five business days.

Start collecting subscribers before your next launch needs them.

📊 Microsoft rolls out its biggest automated bidding upgrade in a decade

Microsoft Advertising is upgrading its automated bidding system to help advertisers spend budgets more effectively, respond faster to campaign changes, and improve conversion performance.

The Breakdown:

  • Microsoft has rebuilt its AI-powered bidding models to better predict which clicks will lead to conversions. The upgrade is rolling out automatically across advertising accounts.
  • Campaigns can now adjust bids nearly twice as fast when CPA or ROAS targets change, while spending budgets more evenly throughout the day.
  • Microsoft's internal testing showed 10% more conversion value per click for value-based bidding, while advertisers switching certain bidding strategies saw up to 18% more conversions.
  • Microsoft recommends at least five account-level conversions before adopting conversion-based bidding. Advertisers should also adjust targets gradually and use accurate conversion values to guide optimization.

Microsoft is making automated bidding faster and more predictable, with further improvements planned for 2027. As the upgrades roll out automatically, advertisers should monitor spending and performance before making major campaign changes.

👨‍💻 Quick Hits

📱 Instagram introduced Story editing for up to 15 minutes after publishing, alongside easier multi-photo selection, new stickers, expanded background gradients, and the ability to search saved posts on iOS.

🔎 Google is rolling out a collapsible sidebar globally on desktop Search, allowing users to revisit recent AI searches, resume previous conversations, and start new AI Mode threads more easily.

📉 Advertisers are cutting Google Ads spending as rising costs and AI Overviews push ads lower in search results, with some businesses shifting budgets to Bing, Reddit, Tubi, and Nextdoor.

📉 Removing blog posts from a London car hire website cut Google AI impressions by 62%, while organic clicks rose 14%, according to a case study questioning AI visibility metrics.

💃Events

🔥 What to Measure Before AI Search Gets Cut From the Budget

Today | 2 PM ET | Virtual Event

Paramark CEO Pranav Piyush and Google Meridian creator Hitesh Wadhwani unpack the three requirements behind credible AI search measurement, where attribution still fails, and how exposure data can fit alongside the channels competing for spend. Take a sharper measurement checklist into your next budget discussion.

✅ Reserve Your Free Seat

Can't attend the session live? Register anyway, and you’ll get the recordings in 24 hours.

That’s a wrap for today! Tell us your thoughts about today's content as we line up more Shorts! And don’t hesitate to share this with someone who’d adore it. 🥰